A good kind of Dilemma?

InterYerMam · Dec 14, 2014

As we all know the January transfer window will open in just a few weeks, and whilst in discussion with a friend of mine last night, he asked "If Argyle were only able to sign one player from our current set of loanees in the window, who would it be?"

To be honest, I couldn't answer him. The choice I think is a difficult one. Personally, out of the three, I would prefer O'Connor. His versatility could be invaluable come the end of the season.

Thoughts?

pearces greens · Dec 14, 2014

InterYerMam":2ny082ru said:
As we all know the January transfer window will open in just a few weeks, and whilst in discussion with a friend of mine last night, he asked "If Argyle were only able to sign one player from our current set of loanees in the window, who would it be?"

To be honest, I couldn't answer him. The choice I think is a difficult one. Personally, out of the three, I would prefer O'Connor. His versatility could be invaluable come the end of the season.

Thoughts?

Thought you couldn't answer him ! :doh:

InterYerMam · Dec 14, 2014

I didn't at the time. I've come to the above after further pondering of the initial question.

pearces greens · Dec 14, 2014

InterYerMam":1g5i8m3n said:
I didn't at the time. I've come to the above after further pondering of the initial question.

and I agree with you :thumbup:

HarlHM · Dec 14, 2014

All 3 are superb, but Kellett.

Leo's Grandad · Dec 14, 2014

Kellett would be my choice

Steve Evans · Dec 14, 2014

o'connor.a class above any player i have seen in this division.he is one of those players that seems to have more time. :clap:

Fergy · Dec 14, 2014

Kellett for me too, we don't have anybody else who could replace him.

Forest of Dean Green · Dec 14, 2014

O'Connor for me. The most composed on the ball player I have seen for Argyle in a while. He keeps it all ticking

StevePAFC · Dec 14, 2014

I can see us keeping at least 2 of them.

Cobi Budge. · Dec 14, 2014

Kellet is either brilliant or quite poor, I'd like to keep him, but I think O'Connor is simply more important.

ealinggreen · Dec 14, 2014

Easy Reid.

macleanie · Dec 14, 2014

O'Connor, we have a great spine of Nelse, O'Connor and Reid. Regular performers for me.

Then K.Reid and Kellett who have both been excellent too.

GreenSam · Dec 14, 2014

Kellett has absolutely bags of potential and on his day can be a fantastic player for us and more natural talent than many players in leagues above never mind this one. One of the best goals and one of the best all round performances I've ever seen yesterday.

O'Connor is a great all-rounder, very consistent and extremely versatile. The classic Lee Hodges esque jack of all trades who's clearly enjoying his time here.

Although out of the three I would have to go for Bobby Reid. He gives us energy and drive from midfield in absolute abundance and it's something that nobody else in our squad has to offer. He can get box to box, cover when we're defending and make stuff happen to a far larger extent than it otherwise would do when we're attacking.

Before Bobby, we were having a mediocre season. During his spell away, we won only won game which was against a shambolic Portsmouth side. With him in the team, we are yet to lose a game. I'm by no means saying we're a one man team but he's our most important loanee and maybe even our most important player full stop. In the top three for sure I think. I'd love us to keep the three but in order of preference I'd just have to say....Reid, then O'Connor, then Kellett.

soccerpilgrim · Dec 14, 2014

Really hard to call. As long as we signed another left-back, I'd probably favour O'Connor or Reid over Kellett, although I do like all three. I think I would pick Reid, but O'Connor's been solid, and on a consistent basis.

A good kind of Dilemma?

Cobi Budge.

Guest