Rate the Ref: John Brooks v Newport FA Cup

PL2 3DQ · Dec 2, 2016

Your thoughts, praise and criticism and marks out of 10 for today's ref John Brooks.

In previous home games the majority of fans have voted the refs at ....

Lee Collins, Luton - 4/10
Brendan Malone, Mansfield - 7/10
Nick Kinseley, Cheltenham - 4/10
Lee Probert, Cambridge - 9/10
Gavin Ward, Hartlepool - 5/10
Seb Stockbridge, Yeovil - 5/10
Darren Handley, Portsmouth - 5/10
Kevin Johnson & Simon Knapp, Colchester - 6/10
Rob Jones, Grimsby - 9/10
Brett Huxtable, Barnet - 1/10

samjones · Dec 3, 2016

Not as bad as the Barnet ref and thought the sending off looked harsh.
Then not wishing to send them down to 9 men he let their No 2 get away with 3 fouls on Carey after he had been yellow carded.

Cant blame the ref for our inept performance against 10 men.
Can't wait for DA's excuse on the 4th p155 poor performance in a row

Pogleswoody · Dec 3, 2016

samjones":2gbo034p said:
Not as bad as the Barnet ref and thought the sending off looked harsh.
Then not wishing to send them down to 9 men he let their No 2 get away with 3 fouls on Carey after he had been yellow carded.
Cant blame the ref for our inept performance against 10 men.
Can't wait for DA's excuse on the 4th p155 poor performance in a row

That merits a low score for the ref surely??

Need to see the sending off, surprised me but I was looking at Jervis pulling out of the challenge so tricky to assess what their guy did.

12thGreen · Dec 3, 2016

Sending off was fair for a two footed challenge, although we do often see just a yellow for the one like today. The full back should have gone as well after the 3rd / 4th bookable challenge, so lacking consistency there. But otherwise seemed to get most of the decisions right today, as did the linesmen. 6/10.

Cobi Budge · Dec 3, 2016

No idea how their full back wasn't sent off, booked early on, must have made 4 or 5 identical fouls in the first half alone.

ping g5 · Dec 4, 2016

Rigg was in the air and stamped into the tackle. Whether we thinks it's harsh or not, under the rules that's a red.

Knarf Reprah · Dec 4, 2016

ping_g5":1xdc8kd8 said:
Rigg was in the air and stamped into the tackle. Whether we thinks it's harsh or not, under the rules that's a red.

Unless you play fir Man Ure

Rate the Ref: John Brooks v Newport FA Cup

Rate the Ref v Newport FA Cup

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

PL2 3DQ

Site Owner

samjones

Pogleswoody

12thGreen

Cobi Budge

ping g5

Knarf Reprah