PASOTI
  • Fantasy Football
  • Predictions
  • Club Info
  • About Us
  • FAQ

Skip to content

Twitter @pasoti1
General Opinions
The place for politics, ranting, banter and complete tripe. Plus dumped 'splits' from main forum.
Sponsored by the CWU Count Me In Campaign.
81 posts Page 1 of 7
Post a reply
Previous 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ... 7 Next

George Floyd

User avatar

Posts: 2379
Joined: 09:56 25 Sep 2010
by Martyn
» 08:12 30 Mar 2021


Everybody is totally entitled to a fair trial.

Looking at the video evidence, ‘yesterday’, which is the first time I have seen it, shown at the opening remarks of the prosecution team, is absolutely damning.

You are watching a man in handcuffs, and grounded, slowly DIE. It is heart wrenching. It is there in full video evidence. His life is being drained from him, by the knee of the policeman, on the man’s neck.

It is a hard watch, but I ask people to see it.

One thought, if this ex policeman is acquitted, it will cause riots in America, never seen before.

Re: George Floyd

User avatar

Posts: 3667
Joined: 11:16 15 Jul 2006
Location: Kenton, Devon
by Quinny
» 09:01 30 Mar 2021


Martyn wrote: Everybody is totally entitled to a fair trial.

Looking at the video evidence, ‘yesterday’, which is the first time I have seen it, shown at the opening remarks of the prosecution team, is absolutely damning.

You are watching a man in handcuffs, and grounded, slowly DIE. It is heart wrenching. It is there in full video evidence. His life is being drained from him, by the knee of the policeman, on the man’s neck.

It is a hard watch, but I ask people to see it.

One thought, if this ex policeman is acquitted, it will cause riots in America, never seen before.


To be honest, I genuinely don't think this will turn out to be a fair trial - both for the accused officer, and for the family of George Floyd. And (and I say this with absolutely no disrespect, Martyn, please believe me on this point) your OP raises my concern for the outcome of the trial: you start by saying everyone is entitled to a fair trial, but then without hearing the case for the defence, either consciously or sub-consciously, you've already come to your conclusion about Chauvin's guilt. This bothers me because if that's the opinion which everyone expects then it isn't going to be a fair trial - Chauvin better be found guilty, otherwise there'll be riots!

Let the defence make their case. It could well be that what's seen in the video is unequivocally the facts, that Chauvin intentionally used excessive force which led to Floyd's death. But it could well be, as per their opening statements, that Floyd's death was caused by other factors and not Chauvin's kneeling technique (which I think is allowed as a police holding technique, if the officer is correctly trained in it) - in which case it could well be accidental death - or it could well be that Chauvin did this with the intention of harming George Floyd (in which case it isn't). Until that happens and after the jury have reached their decision, I won't watch the full video.
www.twitter.com/quinny265

"Ladies and gentlemen, I've suffered for my music ... now it's your turn"
Neil Innes (Bonzo Dog Doo-Dah Band)

Re: George Floyd

User avatar

Posts: 2379
Joined: 09:56 25 Sep 2010
by Martyn
» 14:14 30 Mar 2021


Quinny wrote:
Martyn wrote: Everybody is totally entitled to a fair trial.

Looking at the video evidence, ‘yesterday’, which is the first time I have seen it, shown at the opening remarks of the prosecution team, is absolutely damning.

You are watching a man in handcuffs, and grounded, slowly DIE. It is heart wrenching. It is there in full video evidence. His life is being drained from him, by the knee of the policeman, on the man’s neck.

It is a hard watch, but I ask people to see it.

One thought, if this ex policeman is acquitted, it will cause riots in America, never seen before.


To be honest, I genuinely don't think this will turn out to be a fair trial - both for the accused officer, and for the family of George Floyd. And (and I say this with absolutely no disrespect, Martyn, please believe me on this point) your OP raises my concern for the outcome of the trial: you start by saying everyone is entitled to a fair trial, but then without hearing the case for the defence, either consciously or sub-consciously, you've already come to your conclusion about Chauvin's guilt. This bothers me because if that's the opinion which everyone expects then it isn't going to be a fair trial - Chauvin better be found guilty, otherwise there'll be riots!

Let the defence make their case. It could well be that what's seen in the video is unequivocally the facts, that Chauvin intentionally used excessive force which led to Floyd's death. But it could well be, as per their opening statements, that Floyd's death was caused by other factors and not Chauvin's kneeling technique (which I think is allowed as a police holding technique, if the officer is correctly trained in it) - in which case it could well be accidental death - or it could well be that Chauvin did this with the intention of harming George Floyd (in which case it isn't). Until that happens and after the jury have reached their decision, I won't watch the full video.


Hi Quinny,

Basically, I agree with everything you say. Plus, I intentionally ‘jumped the gun’, and made an assessment of the verdict.

Purely on the basis, to have some discussion , and predict what may happen, if he is acquitted.
The trial is being shown worldwide, and also America is on ‘trial’.

The ex-policeman (will never say his name), will probably not get a fair evidence trial, as the ‘evidence’, is totally against him. He is also ‘ guilty’, in the courtroom of public opinion.

Re: George Floyd

User avatar

Posts: 2362
Joined: 15:36 19 Oct 2011
Location: New York, Paris, Rome, but mainly Chudleigh.
by mervyn
» 14:28 30 Mar 2021


What I find scary is the defence’s opening remarks, and thus their main argument, that the police officer was doing precisely what he was trained to do.
Remember, I before E except when you run a feisty heist on a weird foreign neighbour in Chudleigh.

Re: George Floyd

User avatar

Posts: 3667
Joined: 11:16 15 Jul 2006
Location: Kenton, Devon
by Quinny
» 14:42 30 Mar 2021


mervyn wrote: What I find scary is the defence’s opening remarks, and thus their main argument, that the police officer was doing precisely what he was trained to do.


I believe their manual has been updated after the event, but certainly at the time the Minneapolis police procedure guide listed that as one of two restraint techniques officers could use. It wasn't a technique widely used across 'Murica, though.
www.twitter.com/quinny265

"Ladies and gentlemen, I've suffered for my music ... now it's your turn"
Neil Innes (Bonzo Dog Doo-Dah Band)

Re: George Floyd

User avatar

Posts: 3026
Joined: 12:00 30 Dec 2004
Location: Brighton
by MickyD
» 20:57 30 Mar 2021


I forced myself to watch quite long passages of the video several times when it was first in the news, and what struck me above all else was - that awful phrase - the banality of evil: the matter-of-fact bloody casualness of the whole proceeding, and not just in the way Chauvin himself behaved, with one hand in pocket; but also in the demeanour of the three other officers who were in close attendance throughout. A fellow human being was clearly in serious physical and emotional distress and dying right in front of them, but it just didn't matter.

I know it's been said a million times already, but just imagine "the optics" if Floyd had been white.
PIES - Pilgrims In East Sussex

Re: George Floyd

User avatar

Posts: 1447
Joined: 21:06 02 Sep 2008
by Pottypilgrim
» 06:58 31 Mar 2021


MickyD wrote: I forced myself to watch quite long passages of the video several times when it was first in the news, and what struck me above all else was - that awful phrase - the banality of evil: the matter-of-fact bloody casualness of the whole proceeding, and not just in the way Chauvin himself behaved, with one hand in pocket; but also in the demeanour of the three other officers who were in close attendance throughout. A fellow human being was clearly in serious physical and emotional distress and dying right in front of them, but it just didn't matter.

I know it's been said a million times already, but just imagine "the optics" if Floyd had been white.


What a load of boll@cks. A similar thing has happened to a white person and there wasnt anything near the sort of reaction we've seen here. No rioting in the streets, mass coverage on a global scale in the press or vilification of the police. I wonder why that is? :think:

Re: George Floyd

User avatar

Posts: 2379
Joined: 09:56 25 Sep 2010
by Martyn
» 08:02 31 Mar 2021


Pottypilgrim wrote:
MickyD wrote: I forced myself to watch quite long passages of the video several times when it was first in the news, and what struck me above all else was - that awful phrase - the banality of evil: the matter-of-fact bloody casualness of the whole proceeding, and not just in the way Chauvin himself behaved, with one hand in pocket; but also in the demeanour of the three other officers who were in close attendance throughout. A fellow human being was clearly in serious physical and emotional distress and dying right in front of them, but it just didn't matter.

I know it's been said a million times already, but just imagine "the optics" if Floyd had been white.


What a load of boll@cks. A similar thing has happened to a white person and there wasnt anything near the sort of reaction we've seen here. No rioting in the streets, mass coverage on a global scale in the press or vilification of the police. I wonder why that is? :think:


Potty, that is the point MickyD is making. It would be a whole different scenario if he had been white.

Re: George Floyd

User avatar

Posts: 1447
Joined: 21:06 02 Sep 2008
by Pottypilgrim
» 10:53 31 Mar 2021


Martyn wrote:
Pottypilgrim wrote:
MickyD wrote: I forced myself to watch quite long passages of the video several times when it was first in the news, and what struck me above all else was - that awful phrase - the banality of evil: the matter-of-fact bloody casualness of the whole proceeding, and not just in the way Chauvin himself behaved, with one hand in pocket; but also in the demeanour of the three other officers who were in close attendance throughout. A fellow human being was clearly in serious physical and emotional distress and dying right in front of them, but it just didn't matter.

I know it's been said a million times already, but just imagine "the optics" if Floyd had been white.


What a load of boll@cks. A similar thing has happened to a white person and there wasnt anything near the sort of reaction we've seen here. No rioting in the streets, mass coverage on a global scale in the press or vilification of the police. I wonder why that is? :think:


Potty, that is the point MickyD is making. It would be a whole different scenario if he had been white.


I'm not sure he is making that point at all Martyn. He says, 'A fellow human being was clearly in serious physical and emotional distress and dying right in front of them, but it just didn't matter.' Suggesting that if it were a white person then it would matter and perhaps people/the other police officers would behave/act differently. I'm saying that isn't the case and also added bits about the aftermath/reaction. More than happy to be corrected though...

Re: George Floyd

User avatar

Posts: 10803
Joined: 19:20 06 Sep 2006
by Balham_Green
» 12:52 31 Mar 2021


Pottypilgrim wrote:
MickyD wrote: I forced myself to watch quite long passages of the video several times when it was first in the news, and what struck me above all else was - that awful phrase - the banality of evil: the matter-of-fact bloody casualness of the whole proceeding, and not just in the way Chauvin himself behaved, with one hand in pocket; but also in the demeanour of the three other officers who were in close attendance throughout. A fellow human being was clearly in serious physical and emotional distress and dying right in front of them, but it just didn't matter.

I know it's been said a million times already, but just imagine "the optics" if Floyd had been white.


What a load of boll@cks. A similar thing has happened to a white person and there wasnt anything near the sort of reaction we've seen here. No rioting in the streets, mass coverage on a global scale in the press or vilification of the police. I wonder why that is? :think:


Any examples then?

Re: George Floyd

User avatar

Posts: 1830
Joined: 22:10 03 Aug 2008
Location: Plymouth
by pilgrimage
» 15:25 31 Mar 2021


MickyD wrote: I forced myself to watch quite long passages of the video several times when it was first in the news, and what struck me above all else was - that awful phrase - the banality of evil: the matter-of-fact bloody casualness of the whole proceeding, and not just in the way Chauvin himself behaved, with one hand in pocket; but also in the demeanour of the three other officers who were in close attendance throughout. A fellow human being was clearly in serious physical and emotional distress and dying right in front of them, but it just didn't matter.

I know it's been said a million times already, but just imagine "the optics" if Floyd had been white.


But after all he was arrested under suspicion of using a forged 20 dollar bill!! :furious:
Premier League one day?

Re: George Floyd

User avatar

Posts: 3375
Joined: 10:21 16 May 2016
by Guiri Green
» 17:30 31 Mar 2021


Balham_Green wrote:
Pottypilgrim wrote:
MickyD wrote: I forced myself to watch quite long passages of the video several times when it was first in the news, and what struck me above all else was - that awful phrase - the banality of evil: the matter-of-fact bloody casualness of the whole proceeding, and not just in the way Chauvin himself behaved, with one hand in pocket; but also in the demeanour of the three other officers who were in close attendance throughout. A fellow human being was clearly in serious physical and emotional distress and dying right in front of them, but it just didn't matter.

I know it's been said a million times already, but just imagine "the optics" if Floyd had been white.


What a load of boll@cks. A similar thing has happened to a white person and there wasnt anything near the sort of reaction we've seen here. No rioting in the streets, mass coverage on a global scale in the press or vilification of the police. I wonder why that is? :think:


Any examples then?


This guy was knelt on in 2016. Slightly different as he called the Police after coming off his meds. The police laughed as he died. I used Google as I'd only heard anecdotal evidence of it.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/201 ... tony-timpa

Re: George Floyd

User avatar

Posts: 3320
Joined: 21:57 04 Mar 2012
Location: Plymouth
by justanotherfan
» 18:11 31 Mar 2021
Pauls Flag, Club Donor, Lowey Sponsor, Katie Sponsor


It`s called positional Asphyxia where the compression doesn`t allow the chest to rise and fall, in all training in restraint procedures it is warned about.
The good thing about the internet: It gives everyone a voice.
The bad thing about the internet: It gives everyone a voice
Post a reply
Previous 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ... 7 Next
81 posts Page 1 of 7
Return to Opinions

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Ted and 79 guests

  • Home
  • Fantasy Football
  • Predictions
  • Club Info
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • FAQ

Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group

League Table

Fixtures

News

www.pafc.co.uk/news
Tweets by Pasoti1
twitter.com/pasoti1
Follow @pasoti1

Links

Popular Sites

  • Greens on Screen
  • Official Site
  • Argyle Superstore
  • Match Tickets
  • Argyle Community Trust
  • Home Park Development
  • Argyle Ladies

Fan Sites

  • GOS Daily Diary
  • Green Taverners
  • Argyle Fans' Trust
  • Memories of Argyle
  • Argyle Life

Associations

  • London Branch
  • Cornish Supporters

News & Stats

  • BBC club page
  • News Now
  • Soccerbase
  • Football Ground Guide
  • The team
  • Delete all board cookies
  • All times are UTC

  • Developed by Vertical Plus Ltd | Template: ComBoot by Florian Gareis