I think there's a lot more to a successful defence than is being discussed on this thread. Firstly, stats do not tell the whole story and the chemistry between defenders is vitally important. The three defenders that we have signed so far do appear to offer a very good balance of skill-sets. Wotton and Coughlan are a great example of two defenders who complemented each other beautifully. They also had the character, drive and communication skills that we have been lacking at times at the back recently. These new defenders strike me as being experienced football players who will communicate and organise. It's worth remembering that we have a (highly talented) rookie goalkeeper who could use some protection and assistance from 'old pros' in front of him.
The second factor to consider is coaching. RL is determined to play a 3CB system and this will be the system of choice for the new season. Most defenders at Argyle's level and below will be unfamiliar with this system and so it will be interesting to see who can adapt and who struggles. Mobility is key, as is awareness and communication, and I think we have the right blend of skills and characters but it will be interesting to see how these new players adapt to situations where they are drawn out of the middle and are covering for wing-backs who are in the opposition penalty area! For the record, I would rather watch an attacking Argyle team than a defensive Argyle team but I accept that balance is important.
Finally, the key to a successful defence this season may not lie wholly with the defence itself but with the crucial DCM position. This player will be absolutely vital to the success of Argyle this season and it is clear that we need a very talented and experienced Championship/League One level to offer protection to the defence and keep the ball moving when we have possession. Pallister and Bruce are not as successful without Keane or Ince. Wotton and Coughlan had Stevie Adams, a player much maligned for his supposed lack of ability but vital to Sturrock's formation, especially away from HP. I was hoping that Lewis Macleod would be this player but he appears too injury-prone but I am hopeful that we will be successful in recruiting the right player for this position. It would be interesting to see Randell as the understudy also to continue his development.
Keep it green everyone! :scarf: