Rate the Ref v Bradford

PL2 3DQ · Feb 24, 2018

Your thoughts, praise or criticism and marks out of 10 for today's referee Graham Salisbury.

Previous polls and majority of voting for home games:

Charlton - won. John Brooks 7/10
Scunthorpe - lost. Chris Sarginson 1/10
MK Dons - lost. Charles Breakspear 4/10
Blackpool - lost. Kevin Johnson 3/10
Doncaster - lost. Nick Kinseley 5/10
Fleetwood - lost. Craig Hicks 8/10
Shrewsbury - drew. Mark Heywood 5/10
Rochdale - drew. Gavin Ward 9/10
Grimsby FA Cup - won. John Busby 7/10
Oxford - lost. Graham Horwood 1/10
Northampton - won. Antony Coggins 9/10
Gillingham - won. Darren Handley 7/10
Oldham - won. Lee Collins/Richard Hulme 8/10
Walsall - won. Kevin Johnson 7/10
Bury - won. Trevor Kettle 4/10
Wigan - lost. Gavin Ward 1/10
Blackburn - won. Charles Breakspear 7/10
Wimbledon - won. Brett Huxtable 5/10

landons forehead · Feb 24, 2018

Was far too lenient, game got nasty as a result, hence red card necessary.

Welwyn Pilgrim · Feb 24, 2018

Thought he did ok but reluctant to get his yellow card for some challenges. Bradford quite a nasty side with a few off the ball kicks and digs on Argyle players. Can't remember ever seeing a game where no yellows shown but a red was

Willis88 · Feb 24, 2018

7/10 Did well but allowed too much from both teams.

Game got quite feisty as a result

IJN · Feb 24, 2018

I thought he did very well, but as others have said could have brought a few yellow cards out earlier.

5/10.

samjones · Feb 24, 2018

I thought he had forgotten his cards today until the red. Taylor was man handled all game and their No 22 blatantly dragged him to the floor 5 times and not a single booking ???
Most lenient ref I have ever seen in recent times and not saying that's a bad thing as at least the game wasn't constantly being stopped for silly fouls but in todays no contact game it seemed unusual

Charles Plym · Feb 24, 2018

Refreshingly unfussy , the game was the star not him , old style refereeing and the game was better for it . Excellent

Cobi Budge · Feb 24, 2018

Maybe should have been a bit more forceful but I thought he was fairly good, let the game flow, got the sending off correct. 7/10

r4h4al · Feb 24, 2018

1. Terrible performance. Totally inept.

Cobi Budge · Feb 24, 2018

r4h4al":o8ldv0kp said:
1. Terrible performance. Totally inept.

How so?

I've seen some 1/10 refereeing performances at home park in recent years, but today's definitely wasn't one in my eyes.

Pogleswoody · Feb 24, 2018

Yes got the play right and the game flowed a bit but ... he left his yellow card at home. They had a licence to kick Taylor and bring Carey down. I think if he had booked 2 or 3 their red card man might have realised that it wasn't open season on us.
Gave him 7 ( :shock: ) for refereeing, 2/10 for discipline!

I mean who suggests two professional players shake hands and 'make up' after a foul? They're pros not PYC players FFS! :facepalm:

castlegreen · Feb 24, 2018

Got most things right - but should have Shown his cards earlier

Charles Plym · Feb 24, 2018

r4h4al":14mnvv0o said:
1. Terrible performance. Totally inept.

Only two explanations for that post

Either you are clueless
Or
You are trolling

Nothing else is possible

metroace · Feb 24, 2018

4/10. If he had got a grip on the game earlier, then perhaps the red would not have been necessary.

Alan Turing · Feb 24, 2018

I admire him for trying to keep his cards in his pocket but several challenges warranted more punishment than they got. 6/10

Rate the Ref v Bradford - Graham Salisbury

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

PL2 3DQ

Site Owner

landons forehead

Welwyn Pilgrim

Willis88

IJN

Site Owner

samjones

Charles Plym

Guest

Cobi Budge

r4h4al

Cobi Budge

Pogleswoody

castlegreen

Charles Plym

Guest

metroace

Alan Turing

Administrator