Rate the Ref v Bristol Rovers

PL2 3DQ · Mar 17, 2018

Your thoughts, praise or criticism and marks out of 10 for today's referee John Brooks.

Previous polls and majority of voting for home games:

Charlton - won. John Brooks 7/10
Scunthorpe - lost. Chris Sarginson 1/10
MK Dons - lost. Charles Breakspear 4/10
Blackpool - lost. Kevin Johnson 3/10
Doncaster - lost. Nick Kinseley 5/10
Fleetwood - lost. Craig Hicks 8/10
Shrewsbury - drew. Mark Heywood 5/10
Rochdale - drew. Gavin Ward 9/10
Grimsby FA Cup - won. John Busby 7/10
Oxford - lost. Graham Horwood 1/10
Northampton - won. Antony Coggins 9/10
Gillingham - won. Darren Handley 7/10
Oldham - won. Lee Collins/Richard Hulme 8/10
Walsall - won. Kevin Johnson 7/10
Bury - won. Trevor Kettle 4/10
Wigan - lost. Gavin Ward 1/10
Blackburn - won. Charles Breakspear 7/10
Wimbledon - won. Brett Huxtable 5/10
Bradford - won. Graham Salisbury 7/10

Cobi Budge · Mar 17, 2018

8/10, got most of the big decisions correct.

PAFC94 · Mar 17, 2018

1st pen was soft. Second pen was definitely correct. He's gouged Songo'os eyes out nearly! Was ok. 5/10.

jimbo_the_green · Mar 17, 2018

Thought both pens were a gift. Let a lot of diving go on both sides. Let a lot of time wasting go, generally poor for me but consistently so at least

Leo's Grandad · Mar 17, 2018

Slightly lucky with 1st penalty but 2nd looked nailed on. could have been firmer but would we have criticised him for that ?

r4h4al · Mar 17, 2018

10/10 because he gave us a Penalty.

Dan Ellard · Mar 17, 2018

Bottled sending Partington off, should have been shown a 2nd yellow for that deliberate handball on the edge of the box.

Some weird decisions and some poor misuse of the advantage rule too.

As for the big decisions, I think the Songo'o last man incident really could have gone either way. Likewise the first penalty. Second one was a stone-waller.

5/10.

PAFC94 · Mar 17, 2018

jimbo_the_green":2mmpu0m7 said:
Thought both pens were a gift. Let a lot of diving go on both sides. Let a lot of time wasting go, generally poor for me but consistently so at least

The second pen was a gift from the Rovers player. No idea what he was playing at. You can't claw at a players face.

rsp4 · Mar 17, 2018

Good points I thought he kept control and kept up with the game but I thought he made a few big mistakes.

Their free kick for their first was not a free kick. Our 1st pen was really soft. He could have sent Songo off and Carey was lucky but their defenders hand ball was defo a delibrate attempt.
2nd pen was nailed on.not sure what their defender was doing

Charles Plym · Mar 17, 2018

Awful

Monster Green · Mar 17, 2018

Did well. Handled most situations well. First pen soft, but what I gather the second was a stone wall pen. Happy days!

Pogleswoody · Mar 17, 2018

r4h4al":1csayz8x said:
10/10 because he gave us a Penalty.

20/10 because he gave us two!! :scarf:

Martyn · Mar 17, 2018

Charles.plym":3f21s8tm said:
Awful

Can't stand comments like that , with no back up, or any idea tocome up with a constructive ideas

Kevb77 · Mar 17, 2018

Overall a good performance even though Rovers had what looked like a stonewall penalty turned down, Carey should have been sent off, Songo'o lucky to get away with a couple of clumsy challenges, but he generally controlled what could have been a very volotile game with a cool head.

nick_PASTIE · Mar 17, 2018

Songo should have walked at 0-1, he gave us two debatable pens. And I still only gave him 7. Shows how objective I am.

Rate the Ref v Bristol Rovers - John Brooks

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

PL2 3DQ

Site Owner

Cobi Budge

PAFC94

jimbo_the_green

Leo's Grandad

r4h4al

Dan Ellard

PAFC94

rsp4

Charles Plym

Guest

Monster Green

Pogleswoody

Martyn

Kevb77

nick_PASTIE