Rate the Ref v Peterborough

PL2 3DQ · Apr 7, 2018

Your thoughts, praise or criticism and marks out of 10 for today's referee Craig Hicks.

Previous polls and majority of voting for home games:

Charlton - won. John Brooks 7/10
Scunthorpe - lost. Chris Sarginson 1/10
MK Dons - lost. Charles Breakspear 4/10
Blackpool - lost. Kevin Johnson 3/10
Doncaster - lost. Nick Kinseley 5/10
Fleetwood - lost. Craig Hicks 8/10
Shrewsbury - drew. Mark Heywood 5/10
Rochdale - drew. Gavin Ward 9/10
Grimsby FA Cup - won. John Busby 7/10
Oxford - lost. Graham Horwood 1/10
Northampton - won. Antony Coggins 9/10
Gillingham - won. Darren Handley 7/10
Oldham - won. Lee Collins/Richard Hulme 8/10
Walsall - won. Kevin Johnson 7/10
Bury - won. Trevor Kettle 4/10
Wigan - lost. Gavin Ward 1/10
Blackburn - won. Charles Breakspear 7/10
Wimbledon - won. Brett Huxtable 5/10
Bradford - won. Graham Salisbury 7/10
Bristol Rovers - won. John Brooks 5/10
Southend - won. Brendan Malone 8/10

Graham Evans · Apr 7, 2018

Terrible , one of the worst i have ever seen.

dunlop · Apr 7, 2018

1 from me never had control from the start.

Beyton Green · Apr 7, 2018

Got the job right in the end.

rsp4 · Apr 7, 2018

Awful. Only got strong at the end. He lost control of the game and never regained it

Heathrow Green · Apr 7, 2018

He lost it in the first half and only started to crack down late on. Missed several offences which could have meant that posh finished with 7 or 8 players.

Cobi Budge · Apr 7, 2018

He missed 3 blatant red cards for Peterborough and then gave them one that wasn't even a foul

Stiffler · Apr 7, 2018

Should have booked Oscar and could have sent Taylor off, definite penalty and that idiot deserved his second yellow for deliberately scuffing up penalty spot. Ref was a homer today for sure.

WidewellGreen · Apr 7, 2018

Terrible for both sides. It was obvious from the order that this game needed a cool head and strong officials. He appeared completely overwhelmed from the first whistle.

Dan Ellard · Apr 7, 2018

He'll definitely have quieter afternoons to deal with than that!

Fox and Threlkeld not getting booked was dreadful refereeing. Blatant. Our first half penalty shout - spot on. No pen. Their first red, I didn't see it so couldn't say. Second red and our pen, absolute stone-wallers. But then he completely bottled sending off another of their players in stoppage time for the foul on Grant when in on goal. Also bottled the Taylor decision - wasn't even a yellow.

Very inconsistent towards both teams.

arrythewurzel · Apr 7, 2018

Seemed to over compensate in our favour for some dreadful decisions first half 4/10

supergreen6 · Apr 7, 2018

5 for me. Not one of the best, can only say his performance stayed at a level throughout - unimpressive but not dire.

samjones · Apr 7, 2018

Had a bit of a mare.

Posh should have had another player sent off for the blatant trip on Grant when he was in front of last man and in on goal ???? Most obvious decision all game

Chortle · Apr 7, 2018

2 from me, one for each time he listened to the Grandstand Lino, for the sendings off. Ref didn't see either, trying to kick a divot in the penalty spot wtf! Lyndhurst Lino useless as usual

PL2 3DQ · Apr 7, 2018

He's a first year referee and had a poor first half, he didn't control the antics of Peterborough but credit to him for having a good second half and ultimately gave the decision that allowed us to win the game.

Both managers would have some cause to complain about him.

6/10.

Rate the Ref v Peterborough - Craig Hicks

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

PL2 3DQ

Site Owner

Graham Evans

dunlop

Beyton Green

rsp4

Heathrow Green

Cobi Budge

Stiffler

WidewellGreen

Dan Ellard

arrythewurzel

supergreen6

samjones

Chortle

PL2 3DQ

Site Owner