Rate the Ref v Macclesfield

PL2 3DQ · Mar 7, 2020

Your thoughts, praise or criticism and marks out of 10 for today's referee Chris Sarginson.
The majority of voting in previous home games:

Colchester - John Busby 7/10
L Orient - Antony Coggins 7/10
Salford - Sam Purkiss 5/10
Walsall - Josh Smith 1/10
Reading - Kevin Johnson 8/10
Oldham - Will Finnie 4/10
Cheltenham - Scott Oldham 1/10
Scunthorpe - Andy Woolmer 8/10
Carlisle - Alan Young 6/10
Leyton Orient - Craig Hicks 6/10
Bradford - Ollie Yates 7/10
Morecambe - Brett Huxtable 8/10
Bristol Rovers - Andy Woolmer 1/10
Stevenage - John Busby 8/10
Swindon - Kevin Johnson 8/10
Mansfield - Trevor Kettle 7/10
Crawley - Alan Young 8/10
Newport - Ollie Yates 7/10
Crewe - Tom Nield 7/10
Cambridge - Will Finnie 5/10
Grimsby - David Rock 8/10

Dan Ellard · Mar 7, 2020

Well done for managing not to be a liar this time.

He wasn't brilliant, but he was fine. Excellent effort.

WoodfordWall · Mar 7, 2020

He was okay but too lenient in the opening stages. Should have got the card out a few times more than he did.

Kevb77 · Mar 7, 2020

He was far too lenient with the over aggressive Mac tackles in the opening exchanges. Let lots of niggly fouls go but was picky as fudge with free kicks not being taken from the exact right spot.

A 6 from me.

Welwyn Pilgrim · Mar 7, 2020

So bloody fussy but no glaring mistake as it was down to the Lino who didn’t give the goal when it crossed the line. Even from the Lyndhurst it looked it but I’m sure someone somewhere will confirm it.

Should’ve booked a few more Macc players as could see one of our lot getting hurt..

I’ll give him a 6

Pogleswoody · Mar 7, 2020

6 bad tackles early on .. one yellow card. Weak as a virus handshake! :facepalm:

IJN · Mar 7, 2020

He's a liar. 1.

Charles Plym · Mar 7, 2020

IJN":gx5hiocb said:
He's a liar. 1.

how many do you give him for THIS match though?

freddie2greens · Mar 7, 2020

IJN":1q75nh1k said:
He's a liar. 1.

what do you mean by that ?

Charles Plym · Mar 7, 2020

freddie2greens":1haimv9y said:
IJN":1haimv9y said:

He's a liar. 1.

Click to expand...

what do you mean by that ?

He means that years and years ago in around 1887 this ref said he didn’t see a player push a ball boy , nobody knows regardless of photos appearing to show the ref looking right at it if he did or didn’t however the serial referees hater has made his mind up and that’s that .

IJN · Mar 7, 2020

Three years ago, not really a long time ago was it?

He should have been sacked for obviously lying, but of course the ref's club formed a circle.

Mark Pedlar · Mar 7, 2020

IJN":1q0186mr said:
Three years ago, not really a long time ago was it?

He should have been sacked for obviously lying, but of course the ref's club formed a circle.

They always do - you see it on here. It's like they're all masons.

IJN · Mar 7, 2020

Exactly, no logic just dedication to the black shirt and whistle. .

Willis88 · Mar 7, 2020

Anywho, back to today...

Certainly should have got the card out in the first 10 mins or so to stop the Mac tackles, I was worried someone would pick up a nasty injury if he didn't stop them.

Otherwise had a fairly decent game.

7 from me, be less picky about the free kicks and clamp down on the rough tackles.

rsp4 · Mar 7, 2020

Didn't even realise it was Sargison today.

As his last game I actually thought he did ok. It wasn't a bad match to ref and he did it Ok.

That twice I have said he had been ok. Didn't see that coming a few seasons ago :shock:

Rate the Ref v Macclesfield - Chris Sarginson

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

PL2 3DQ

Site Owner

Dan Ellard

WoodfordWall

Kevb77

Welwyn Pilgrim

Pogleswoody

IJN

Site Owner

Charles Plym

Guest

freddie2greens

Charles Plym

Guest

IJN

Site Owner

Mark Pedlar

Administrator

IJN

Site Owner

Willis88

rsp4