Who are these three hat-trick scorers?

A. I never managed a League game for the first team but only Sammy Black and Jack Vidler managed to score three goals at Home Park before a bigger crowd than me.

B. I scored a hat-trick at Home Park in my first cup game for Argyle but never managed another goal in any of my other cup ties for the club.

C. I did my best to serve up a festive goal feast but none of the Green Army went home happy.

C = Tommy Tynan. Got all 3 for Argyle during a Boxing Day loss at Bristol City.

B - Mike Bickle

I reckon c is Richard Landon in the 8-1 win at Hartlepool

A: just guessing here, but I believe there was a crowd in excess of 20,000 for a reserve
game back in the 60's, when tickets for the Spurs FA Cup game were available. Did someone
manage a hat-trick in that game ?

Spot on Gary S!

......and his name was?

Spot on Gary S!

......and his name was?

Ah, got me there

From previous threads, several posters on here have
mentioned that they were at the game, so hopefully one
will be along in a minute to supply the name.

A quick trip to my handbooks reveals Alex Garden ( I know...me neither) scored three v Mansfield Reserves in front of 20K+

Made one appearance for the first team v West Ham in the League Cup before heading away to Ashford....

Made one final appearance at Home Park as part of the Corby team despatched 6-0 in the FA Cup


GOS I love you

GOS I love you

GOS I love you

Get a (chat)room you two!!

Just a couple of bits of trivia to round this off....

The Corby game was the one in which Mike Bickle scored his only cup goals.

The Tynan hat trick is, as far I can see, the only 'losing' hat trick by an Argyle player. Happy to stand corrrected on this.

The Tynan hat trick is, as far I can see, the only 'losing' hat trick by an Argyle player. Happy to stand corrected on this.

I've just asked the question and you're right SG.

There have been two 'drawing' hat-tricks though:
https://www.greensonscreen.co.uk/gosdb- ... =1931-9-12 (Jack Leslie)
and in the Football League South: https://www.greensonscreen.co.uk/gosdb- ... =1945-8-25 (Ron Brown)