New defence required | PASOTI
  • Welcome to PASOTI. Sponsored by Lang & Potter

New defence required

Daz

Administrator
Staff member
✅ Evergreen
Pasoti Quiz Champions
✨Pasoti Donor✨
Sep 30, 2003
8,275
7,356
44
I hate it when fans slate a player specifically, but our defence really isn’t good enough. Some of the individual errors this season have been school boy stuff. Is it a confidence thing with a keeper too? I don’t know, but it’s clear changes are needed. We fold like a pack of cards.
 

Daz

Administrator
Staff member
✅ Evergreen
Pasoti Quiz Champions
✨Pasoti Donor✨
Sep 30, 2003
8,275
7,356
44
I’ll also add the amount of absolute sitters with just a defender on the goal line to beat we manage to miss really is unbelievable.
 
Mar 21, 2006
481
326
Sturrock had Sloop as defensive coach. We need a coach who really understands defending ffs. Lowe and Schuey were both attackers.
 

up the line

🚑 Steve Hooper
🌟Sparksy Mural🌟
Mar 7, 2010
7,575
3,801
Manchester
I can kind of accept a player being just a bit crap.
But stopping when the ref doesn't give a goal kick, then walking into position, then not even moving a neck muscle as the ball goes past you and into your side of the goal.
I'd be having Canavan in at 5 am tomorrow to watch that piece of footage on repeat until the rest of them get in for their individual briefings
 

Daz

Administrator
Staff member
✅ Evergreen
Pasoti Quiz Champions
✨Pasoti Donor✨
Sep 30, 2003
8,275
7,356
44
up_the_line":yc9vc25s said:
I can kind of accept a player being just a bit crap.
But stopping when the ref doesn't give a goal kick, then walking into position, then not even moving a neck muscle as the ball goes past you and into your side of the goal.
I'd be having Canavan in at 5 am tomorrow to watch that piece of footage on repeat until the rest of them get in for their individual briefings

Yep, just lots of consistent errors leading to goals. Not good enough.

Agree about a defensive coach too. There is something missing there.
 
Aug 24, 2014
1,603
602
Plymouth
up_the_line":3csdlxeb said:
I can kind of accept a player being just a bit crap.
But stopping when the ref doesn't give a goal kick, then walking into position, then not even moving a neck muscle as the ball goes past you and into your side of the goal.
I'd be having Canavan in at 5 am tomorrow to watch that piece of footage on repeat until the rest of them get in for their individual briefings

That's the frustration. They're not a world beating defence, but the mistakes aren't solely down to player quality., Sunday league players know to play to the whistle.
 

The Doctor

🏆 Callum Wright 23/24
✨Pasoti Donor✨
Sep 15, 2003
8,892
4,296
Plymouth
andapoet.blog
PlymOdi":bw35z4ia said:
up_the_line":bw35z4ia said:
I can kind of accept a player being just a bit crap.
But stopping when the ref doesn't give a goal kick, then walking into position, then not even moving a neck muscle as the ball goes past you and into your side of the goal.
I'd be having Canavan in at 5 am tomorrow to watch that piece of footage on repeat until the rest of them get in for their individual briefings

That's the frustration. They're not a world beating defence, but the mistakes aren't solely down to player quality., Sunday league players know to play to the whistle.

They might know it but I bet they don’t always do it.
 
Jun 27, 2019
6,508
6,875
The only crumb of comfort to come out of last night is that Lowe and Schumacher can't possibly still think Wootton and Canavan are League One standard. They were poor signings when they first came in: Wootton had just been part of a relegated defence and Canavan wasn't even playing for struggling Rochdale. It's fair to say both have lived up to their low-key billing.

That said, I could see why Lowe kept them around in the summer. Even though neither of them convinced me last season, they had clearly earned RL's trust and helped win him a promotion. It would have been ruthless in the extreme to let them go after that.

But it's now obvious to all and sundry that League Two is their ceiling. In fact, Wootton is probably National League standard, and even then his levels of concentration are so poor that he'd still make mistakes even in that league. I've lost track of the number of times he gets caught ball-watching, letting his man run off him in behind (just like he did last night in the build-up to Rochdale's third - it was almost comical).

As a defender, it's not really about how many headers you win or tackles you make, that's your fundamentals of defending and any professional should win his fair share of those (it's like saying a goalkeeper is a "good shot stopper"; of course he bloody is, that's why he's in goal). There's so much more to it, though: mentality, concentration and focus are what separates the good players from the bad ones. Wootton scores low on all three and needs to go to a league where his lack of focus won't cost his team too many goals.

You get stick on Pasoti for constantly criticising a player, but I like to think I've always been fair on Wootton and given him his dues when he's had a rare good game. I praised him for his first-half at Leyton Orient earlier this season, when he was excellent (though he inevitably dropped a clanger in the second-half that cost us the game), and towards the tail-end of last season when he seemed much more composed on the ball and even his distribution was vastly improved. Unfortunately he keeps reverting to type, and it's now obvious that he's only ever going to be a liability for us if we stay in League One. He isn't up to it. Simple as.

All that said, unfortunately both Wootton and Canavan signed new deals last summer so I'd imagine we're stuck with them until 2022 - unless they only signed one-year deals. Maybe we can find someone willing to take one or both of them for free, but I won't hold my breath.
 
Sep 6, 2006
16,422
3,962
silkman":1qvqdw7c said:
Sturrock had Sloop as defensive coach. We need a coach who really understands defending ffs. Lowe and Schuey were both attackers.

Well, the attackers are not doing much better. That's the worry. A cr@p defence is one thing but we are short of quality up front too.
 

Daz

Administrator
Staff member
✅ Evergreen
Pasoti Quiz Champions
✨Pasoti Donor✨
Sep 30, 2003
8,275
7,356
44
Balham_Green":b1xe51m5 said:
silkman":b1xe51m5 said:
Sturrock had Sloop as defensive coach. We need a coach who really understands defending ffs. Lowe and Schuey were both attackers.

Well, the attackers are not doing much better. That's the worry. A cr@p defence is one thing but we are short of quality up front too.

Its poor how many decent chance we miss within the 6 yard box.

Last night for their second you knew he was going to bury it as it was a decent chance, i'm not sure any of our players are confident enough to do that at the minute and i'd bet they would have put it in the Devonport end.
 

PL2 3DQ

Site Owner
🏆 Callum Wright 23/24
Jade Berrow 23/24
✨Pasoti Donor✨
🌟Sparksy Mural🌟
Oct 31, 2010
24,131
10,007
I think we miss the experience and leadership of Gary Sawyer. Watts is playing well but he's no leader.

Sawyer, Wootton, Canavan and Palmer had the third best defensive record and most number of clean sheets in League Two last season so you can see why Wootton and Canavan have been given a chance this season.

If you add in a rookie keeper, the absence of Sawyer and playing in a higher league against better strikers it's fair to say it's not working.

There's also the midfield which didn't help out. Fornah can have the odd good game but it seems our best defensive midfielder is Macleod who has somehow disappeared.

All of a sudden the January transfer window looks important.
 
May 27, 2019
2,995
308
EXETER/OWLERTON
Pop Sawyer into that back 3 alongside Wootton and Canavan and relegation would probably be a nailed on certainty. None of those three are L1 players, said it before and they’re just piling pressure on a young keeper who is also not ready for this level. Big fan of Lowe but he’s made a fundamental error there. You need a good defence in this league. He got away with it last season due to a style which created goals against poorer quality players. Not this season.
 
May 21, 2010
589
71
taunton
There is no player in midfield or defence that I call a get stuck in kind of player, we are too powderpuff now. Sarcevic was the difference last season. Can't have Wooton or Canavan back in defence again, just too slow and always an accident waiting to happen.