The fact this thread hasn't already been started I see a positive. Personally I thought he was very good, not excellent but certainly one of the better referees I've seen recently. Was only hoodwinked on one real occasion when he booked Edwards for standing his ground and their player ran into him so he got booked but I thought that was down to Phil Browns reaction more than anything else. Kept a lid on the game and booked players for obvious "pull backs" on opponents. Thought he did well and the fact no one has mentioned him since the game finished, both fans and managers alike is maybe evidence to support the fact about his performance.