Josh Pope":rvinj6zn said:neilbet79":rvinj6zn said:Balham_Green":rvinj6zn said:neilbet79":rvinj6zn said:The-Pilgrim":rvinj6zn said:neilbet79":rvinj6zn said:Not sure Taylor is good enough.
Not sure how you can come to that opinion quite yet. He was very effective last season but has barely played this season, don't think you can say with any certainty he won't make the step up.
I didn't say it with certainty to be fair. However, both Oxford and Pompey both let him go as a league 2 player, nothing on the face of it gives me confidence that he is anything but an okay hold-up forward of League 2 standard.
Given our lack of options at the moment I sincerely hope I'm wrong.
Wrong. Oxford let him go in League 1.
Well done. But they still let him go.
If this logic was applied everywhere then players would never move anywhere. Players fit and play differently at different clubs - it isn't the hardest concept to grasp, is it?
Graham Carey got released by Ross County - do you think they'd release him for nothing if he was playing for them like he is now?
At ease soldier.
I simply said at the beginning that I was "not sure" whether Ryan Taylor is good enough for league 1. Purely an observation or opinion if you will. The example of Taylor will not fit into every paradigm of player that has been released by a club and went on to be a successful elsewhere.