Derek Adams has made 33 signings and 17 loan signings in his time as manager and I reckon he has a 48% success rate of signing very good players, a 30% rate of signing a dud and 22% rate of signing a player that just does a job and is bang average.
It’s obviously
subjective, fans will have their favourite signings and no doubt many will disagree with my rating for players such as Miller, Spencer or Slew
. Adams success rate or otherwise is consistent whether it’s a permanent signing or a loan signing.
Boateng and Wylde both had good first spells and were poor second time around, although a lot depends on selection for the first 11, for instance Ainsworth might be a very good player but isn’t getting a run in the team to show us what he can do and until recently most fans would have said Lameiras was a dud signing.
Permanent Signings
Lionel Ainsworth – average, still time to be a hit
Nathan Blissett – average
Sonny Bradley - hit
Nauris Bulvitis – average
Graham Carey - hit
Toumani Diagouraga - hit
Ryan Donaldson – average
Vincent Dorel – miss, not enough games
Ryan Edwards - hit
David Fox - hit
David Goodwillie- miss
Joel Grant - hit
David Ijaha - miss
Jake Jervis - hit
Ruben Lameiras – hit, just
Kyle Letheren - hit
Gary Miller – average
Marc McCallum – miss, not enough games
Jamie Ness – miss, still time to be a hit
Karleigh Osborne - miss
Antoni Sarcevic – average
Josh Simpson - miss
Jordan Slew – hit
Connor Smith – average
Jakub Sokolik - miss
Yann Songo’o - hit
Jimmy Spencer - hit
Ryan Taylor - hit
Aaron Taylor-Sinclair - hit
Robbert te Loeke - miss
Oscar Threlkeld - hit
Gregg Wylde 1 – hit
Gregg Wylde 2 – miss
33 signings = 16 hit (48.5%), 10 miss (30.3%), 7 average (21.2%).
Loans
Hiram Boateng 1 - hit
Hiram Boateng 2 - miss
Nadir Ciftci - miss
Luke Croll - miss
Jordon Foster – average
Arnold Garita – average
Jordan Houghton – average
Matty Kennedy - hit
Will Mannion – average, only 1 game
Jamille Matt - hit
Remi Matthews - hit
Daniel Nardiello - miss
Kelle Roos - hit
Craig Tanner 1 - hit
Craig Tanner 2 - hit
Oscar Thelkeld - hit
Christian Walton – miss
17 loan signings = 8 hit (47.1%), 5 miss (29.4%), 4 average (23.5%).