If you could take 3 players from argyle history....

[Ray Stidwell]

Jack Chisholm
Johnny Hore
Johnny Williams

 

[Frank Butcher]

Defence is the problem.

Jim Furnell
Gordon Nisbet
Graham Coughlan

 

[the corkscrew]

Marker
Nisbet
Morrison

 

[gaspargomez]

Andy Morrison
Nicky Marker
Steve Castle

If Argyle didn't have a crap defence my choices would have been different.

 

[santos73]

Winston Foster
Duncan Neale
Norman Piper

 

[jerryatricjanner]

For where we are weak at the moment, Furnell, Nisbet and Mark Smith.

 

[macleanie]

Capaldi
Coughlan
Cathcart

They would really strengthen us defensively and make us stronger at set pieces.

 

[Kevin Pedlar]

Mark smith
Paul Mariner
Graham Coughlan

 

[Kevin Pedlar]

Second trio

Sonny Bradley
Zak Vyner
Oscar Threlkeld

 

[yashin]

Tommy Tynan
Jimmy Gauld
Alan Nicholls

 

[Presto]

George Robertson
Tony Book
both the best full backs to grace HP
Tommy Tynan to place along side Taylor.

 

[Kentishgreen]

Mariner
Nisbet
Mark Smith

Closely followed by

Bason
Furnell
Delve

 

[paula]

Pat Jones
Billy Rafferty
Paul Mariner

 

[Swillyboy]

It would really be Paul Mariner, Bill Rafferty and Jim Furnell but they have all been mentioned before - as have many other greats - and one or two not so greats. So:

Johnny Newman, Ernie Machin, Fred Binney

 

[r4h4al]

Sammy Black, Paul Mariner, Jim Furnell