Nelson tribunal (Argyle to receive £200-£280k)

[X Isle]

I don't think we will get anywhere near that. The fact he's going to a Premiership side shows more potential than Nelson going to L1.

I think we are looking at £100k with various add ons and clauses

We must try to ensure that we get a decent sell on clause.

...AND a promotion clause, much like the one that saw a mini windfall from Barnsley going up.

The money from L1 to the championship isn't as insignificant as L2 to L1 so Oxford would have plenty and wouldn't begrudge us a slice, they'd be too busy celebrating.

 

[Pogleswoody]

I don't think we will get anywhere near that. The fact he's going to a Premiership side shows more potential than Nelson going to L1.

I think we are looking at £100k with various add ons and clauses

Nelson £100k?

Pogba £100m?

:think:

 

[signalspast]

Whilst it was rejected a championship club did try to sign nelson. we do not know if he was approached directly by them but he chose to go to oxford. So yes I think we should expect the same sort of figures

 

[Quintrell Green]

I don't think we will get anywhere near that. The fact he's going to a Premiership side shows more potential than Nelson going to L1.

I think we are looking at £100k with various add ons and clauses

Nelson £100k?

Pogba £100m?

:think:

Both ex-Premiership trainees too!

 

[Adam R]

Sweeney moved to the PL and was younger, but Nelson has played 2.5times more games and was captain and is still only 24.

 

[cheshiregreen]

More insightful reporting from the journo covering for the absent Mr Errington. This is a sarcastic comment.

http://m.plymouthherald.co.uk/curtis-ne ... story.html

Is there any new news reported here?

 

[Knarf Reprah]

Sarcasm from the comic?bsurely not

 

[PilgrimLew]

The horse has already bolted, trying to now barter with Oxford after we've managed one of our star players contract so badly is silly. The ball is in oxfords court and they hold all the cards while we have a very wobbly leg to stand on. Am I right in thinking Nelson left on a free because his contract was run down?

 

[ealinggreen]

He is not on a free.

 

[Plymouth85Green]

Well how much would you of accepted for him if he were to be signed on a transfer for OXford?

I said that he was worth no less than 350k with add ons.

 

[HC Green]

The horse has already bolted, trying to now barter with Oxford after we've managed one of our star players contract so badly is silly. The ball is in oxfords court and they hold all the cards while we have a very wobbly leg to stand on. Am I right in thinking Nelson left on a free because his contract was run down?

The reason there is a tribunal is because he is under 24. The new club is supposed to compensate the former club for the cost of developing the player. Things like length of time at the club and games played come into the reckoning for working out the compensation.

 

[Lundan Cabbie]

The horse has already bolted, trying to now barter with Oxford after we've managed one of our star players contract so badly is silly. The ball is in oxfords court and they hold all the cards while we have a very wobbly leg to stand on. Am I right in thinking Nelson left on a free because his contract was run down?

The reason there is a tribunal is because he is under 24. The new club is supposed to compensate the former club for the cost of developing the player. Things like length of time at the club and games played come into the reckoning for working out the compensation.

On that criteria it looks good for Argyle. However they will also consider what he was earning and also what contract offer Argyle made him. Unfortunately, that is confidential information as far as fans are concerned so it becomes hard to guess what any tribunal might award.

 

[cheshiregreen]

Decision next week.

http://m.plymouthherald.co.uk/fee-for-f ... story.html

 

[jerryatricjanner]

What does everyone expect us to get? I think we will try for 600k and probably end up with about 300k plus an add on clause from a future transfer. Anything over that will be a bonus in my book.

 

[X Isle]

Not that it should matter but it can't help that he's been out injured. Had he been playing regularly and performing well it would surely have helped.