Your favourite...

[davie nine]

Johnny Williams, closely followed by Peter Anderson.

 

[GreenThing]

Johnny Williams, closely followed by Peter Anderson.

Wondered why anyone would mention Peter Anderson in any favourite list, then I realised I was thinking of Dougie.

 

[Lousy Pint]

Neil Hague, Steve Davey and, of course, Jimmy Hinch.

 

[Emu]

1988 for me, so Kenny Brown and Mark Stuart.

 

[Gary Wills]

Back in 90, Big Jock.

Bit before Dwight’s time, he’s a hero.

 

[Ade the green]

Jock Morrison.

A tackle in the penalty area at the Demport end against Blackpool that saw him sent off, Why? went home and saw the highlights including his two footed lunge. Oh, that would do it!.

 

[edengreen]

89 - Nicky Marker for me, qualify in midfield and would do a great Job for Argyle in his prime now
Sarce reminds me a bit of him but I think Marker was stronger at the surging runs.
Could tackle as well just ask Ossie Ardiles on his welcome to Plymouth !!

 

[Quintrell Green]

At the age of 16 years, it has to be Wilfie Carter for me. It is goals that count in football and he was a regular scorer for a few seasons, whilst being modest with it. There was no running around with an arm aloft in the manner of Law or Shearer.

 

[Luscomio]

2002 so it would be Ian Stonebridge. Not the most prolific but still remains the only player I've had the name of on the back of my shirt.

 

[TheBoldman]

Steve Castle, no question. (Thank you to Greensonscreen for reminding me who was in the Argyle squad when I was 16!)

Honourable mentions also to Peter Shilton and Dwight Marshall.

 

[Martin Brock]

Ronnie Mauge, Kevin Nugent and Ray Newland (yes, I know he wasn't a great player but he was a lovely bloke!)

 

[davie nine]

Newiand?
I know he has made a business success selling keepers’ gloves etc , and all credit to him, but, surely, he comes near the bottom of a list of the worst keepers that have played for Argyle.

 

[rsp4]

Chris Harrison presented me with my player of the season trophy at U15s I think so at 16 he was always up there for me. But Sir Tommy T was the man I watched in awe at 16

 

[Adam R]

Daveeed (although used to like Stonebridge as well)

 

[falmouthgreen]

Johhny Williams for me. 75 years an Argyle supporter.!! None could shoot better from outside the Box than Williams.