PL2 3DQ":1c3ag4su said:Charles.plym":1c3ag4su said:you are quite right it was no accident it was a deliberate dive and cheating fully endorsed by the referee who was either incompetent or corrupt !arrythewurzel":1c3ag4su said:basingstokegreen":1c3ag4su said:Doesn't know the laws of the game nor followed guidance given by the FA to all referees at start of season
Incompetecentre at its worst
If you’re talking about the pen. Incorrect. There was nothing accidental about Edwards challenge and so double jeopardy ruling doesn’t feature in refs decision. I’d have been raging if no pen had been given in our favour in similar circs. We’re not bottom because of refereeing decisions - managerial decisions.
You are normally the first to defend referee's or criticise those who criticise refs so Horwood must have been really bad.
ealinggreen":3182wcv3 said:I thought it was a sending off. Silly decision by Edwards.
katkin":3hljvz6p said:I'm assuming we have 16 Oxford fans on here as they were the only ones who could possibly score him 10/10
Lundan Cabbie":1o0c0tjs said:shortbred":1o0c0tjs said:arrythewurzel":1o0c0tjs said:basingstokegreen":1o0c0tjs said:Doesn't know the laws of the game nor followed guidance given by the FA to all referees at start of season
Incompetecentre at its worst
If you’re talking about the pen. Incorrect. There was nothing accidental about Edwards challenge and so double jeopardy ruling doesn’t feature in refs decision. I’d have been raging if no pen had been given in our favour in similar circs. We’re not bottom because of refereeing decisions - managerial decisions.
You’re now letting your own opinions on Adams impede your knowledge of the game. There was minimal (if any) contact for the penalty. I don’t think it was, but whether it was or wasn’t, the double jeopardy DOES come into play. If a genuine attempt is made to play the ball and it’s a foul it’s a yellow card. They went shoulder to shoulder, the striker went down and he gave a penalty and a red card. Incorrect on both.
That's your opinion but the Laws of the Game clearly state "in the opinion of the REFEREE" who clearly thought it was a deliberate foul.
PL2 3DQ":1sfzf7zx said:katkin":1sfzf7zx said:I'm assuming we have 16 Oxford fans on here as they were the only ones who could possibly score him 10/10
We do get a few from other Argyle websites and Facebook attempting to spoil the vote. Because of that we've unfortunately had to stop guests voting in the polls as from today. Apologies to the genuine guests who usually take part.
PL2 3DQ":1e59qmqh said:katkin":1e59qmqh said:I'm assuming we have 16 Oxford fans on here as they were the only ones who could possibly score him 10/10
We do get a few from other Argyle websites and Facebook attempting to spoil the vote. Because of that we've unfortunately had to stop guests voting in the polls as from today. Apologies to the genuine guests who usually take part.
Just going to say the sameFrazer Lloyd-Davies":y8nyhs8z said:Penalty every day of the week. If the shoe was on the other foot we'd be saying it was a concrete penalty.
Nonetheless what gets me is the red card. Watch the Man City highlights and tell me how Kompany gets away with a yellow compared to our red.