Kelle Roos joins on an emergency loan (ball over the line?)

[Altarnun Green]

I thought it was in from my view in Block 10. However, looking at the replay, Martin who was the closest Gills player made a half hearted appeal and continued on with the game. Didn't make too much fuss at all.

 

[FourMarkGreen]

It's been debated on here for 24 hours with slow-mo replays, freeze frames etc - with no agreement.

The ref/lino had what - maybe 2s to decide in real-time? If they weren't sure, then it was no goal.

 

[Biggs]

Exactly.

 

[Steve Evans]

I know it was his debut for us but he looked nervous with a mistake or several in him all game.
For such a big guy he didn't come for crosses either.
Gills keeper looked good and was massive

roos played for the winning team and the gills 'keeper played on the losing side.

 

[katkin]

I thought in until o saw the lack of protests by gills players. Guess match day moments will likely have more footage

 

[IJN]

I thought it was 100%, now i've seen the replays, I say it wasn't.

 

[r4h4al]

I thought it was 100%, now i've seen the replays, I say it wasn't.

Funny that. Yeah I think the referee made the right decision and looks like it was a great save by Roos. :scarf: :scarf:

 

[Neilz]

Proves what I thought behind the goal; he scoops it back out. If only Charlie Rose would publish such moments. He must have it from behind.

Scoops it back out? Might be worth watching goal rush where the commentator and the slow motion disagree with what your saying, not sure if spec savers are open tomorrow

We're only going round in circles. I was yards from it, they weren't. I'm right, they're wrong.

Match day moments are out, written apology accepted, no where near over the line

 

[rsp4]

Proves what I thought behind the goal; he scoops it back out. If only Charlie Rose would publish such moments. He must have it from behind.

Scoops it back out? Might be worth watching goal rush where the commentator and the slow motion disagree with what your saying, not sure if spec savers are open tomorrow

We're only going round in circles. I was yards from it, they weren't. I'm right, they're wrong.

Match day moments are out, written apology accepted, no where near over the line

No need to apologise that is well and truely in whilst in the air. Match day moments prove it

 

[Neilz]

Proves what I thought behind the goal; he scoops it back out. If only Charlie Rose would publish such moments. He must have it from behind.

Scoops it back out? Might be worth watching goal rush where the commentator and the slow motion disagree with what your saying, not sure if spec savers are open tomorrow

We're only going round in circles. I was yards from it, they weren't. I'm right, they're wrong.

Match day moments are out, written apology accepted, no where near over the line

No need to apologise that is well and truely in whilst in the air. Match day moments prove it

:facepalm: :funny:

 

[Biggs]

As great as Matchday Moments is, it doesn’t have a good angle to see for sure. The best one so far is the official match highlights angle, where I’m 99% sure it doesn’t go over.

The very fact that there’s such a debate about it after countless views of replays, just shows that the referee couldn’t possibly be sure in real-time and therefore could never have given it.

 

[Keepitgreen]

As great as Matchday Moments is, it doesn’t have a good angle to see for sure. The best one so far is the official match highlights angle, where I’m 99% sure it doesn’t go over.

The very fact that there’s such a debate about it after countless views of replays, just shows that the referee couldn’t possibly be sure in real-time and therefore could never have given it.

That's because the ref couldn't see it at all. The first thing he does is look at the lino. He couldn't see it because of the position of Kelle's body. We had no such obstruction - it was over. :lol: :lol: :lol:

 

[PL2 3DQ]

On Matchday Moments there's a camera in the corner of the goal that shows our second goal but there's no footage from this camera for the ghost goal. That camera would have given us a good angle of the ball over the line.

Maybe it's better for the club not to show this definite footage of the ball over the line, all other camera angles leave it open to interpretation.

 

[r4h4al]

On Matchday Moments there's a camera in the corner of the goal that shows our second goal but there's no footage from this camera for the ghost goal. That camera would have given us a good angle of the ball over the line.

Maybe it's better for the club not to show this definite footage of the ball over the line, all other camera angles leave it open to interpretation.

I think the Matchday Moments footage prove it didn't cross the line.

 

[Keepitgreen]

On Matchday Moments there's a camera in the corner of the goal that shows our second goal but there's no footage from this camera for the ghost goal. That camera would have given us a good angle of the ball over the line.

Maybe it's better for the club not to show this definite footage of the ball over the line, all other camera angles leave it open to interpretation.

Exactly my thoughts.