Quite the opposite actually. It proves nothing as you couldn't possibly tell from that angle.r4h4al":2ris836m said:PL2 3DQ":2ris836m said:On Matchday Moments there's a camera in the corner of the goal that shows our second goal but there's no footage from this camera for the ghost goal. That camera would have given us a good angle of the ball over the line.
Maybe it's better for the club not to show this definite footage of the ball over the line, all other camera angles leave it open to interpretation.
I think the Matchday Moments footage prove it didn't cross the line.
Argy1e":21gc9bi8 said:Quite the opposite actually. It proves nothing as you couldn't possibly tell from that angle.r4h4al":21gc9bi8 said:PL2 3DQ":21gc9bi8 said:On Matchday Moments there's a camera in the corner of the goal that shows our second goal but there's no footage from this camera for the ghost goal. That camera would have given us a good angle of the ball over the line.
Maybe it's better for the club not to show this definite footage of the ball over the line, all other camera angles leave it open to interpretation.
I think the Matchday Moments footage prove it didn't cross the line.
Keepitgreen":3hpm7c9v said:That's because the ref couldn't see it at all. The first thing he does is look at the lino. He couldn't see it because of the position of Kelle's body. We had no such obstruction - it was over. :lol: :lol: :lol:Biggs":3hpm7c9v said:As great as Matchday Moments is, it doesn’t have a good angle to see for sure. The best one so far is the official match highlights angle, where I’m 99% sure it doesn’t go over.
The very fact that there’s such a debate about it after countless views of replays, just shows that the referee couldn’t possibly be sure in real-time and therefore could never have given it.
FourMarksGreen":1cp2l0w1 said:Ha ha - look at the vote results: In - 8 votes, Out - 8 votes, Don't know - 2 votes.
Sounds like the ref & lino correctly made the only call they could in that case :thumbup:
Aaron D.":vfe5a7gj said:Id be interested to hear from anyone who had a seat looking right down the goal line, only they would be able to see if the ball was over or not. All other angles could be misleading including the lino's if he wasn't looking down the line. If he wasn't sure it was over then he made the right call not giving a goal.
Biggs":2dihvbjm said:Aaron D.":2dihvbjm said:Id be interested to hear from anyone who had a seat looking right down the goal line, only they would be able to see if the ball was over or not. All other angles could be misleading including the lino's if he wasn't looking down the line. If he wasn't sure it was over then he made the right call not giving a goal.
Even then they are recounting a nano second from over two days ago.
At the time, a lot of people were saying it was WAY over... well we know that wasn’t the case, at least.