Graham Evans":29v0gb70 said:I was right in line and had a perfect view , the ball was at least 6 inches over the line.
Thanks Graham, it was a goal then. Especially as other people in line have also said it was a goal.
Graham Evans":29v0gb70 said:I was right in line and had a perfect view , the ball was at least 6 inches over the line.
Frank_Butcher":8hrhe5qv said:It was the linesman who made the decision - the ref looked over to him and he made a very animated 'no goal' signal. However, as I looked down at the point of the incident from Block 8, the lino was still in motion towards the touchline (understandably as he would have been monitoring the line of defence for offside). I can't see how he, or any linesman in such a situation can make that call reliably - not criticising, just saying it isn't possible.
katkin":1kd3pm37 said:https://twitter.com/kellsroos/status/940236769374519297
That's after he's pulled it back.katkin":16519c3j said:https://twitter.com/kellsroos/status/940236769374519297
Argyle-sy":1fsyw0f7 said:To be fair I have only seen the highlights which were shown on Sky's EFL page, and it did look well over from that camera angle, but as others have said camera angles can be deceptive, so I just we will never know unless someone who was directly in line with the incident managed to capture footage of the incident.
X Isle":2b0poy45 said:There's no probably about it.
Keepitgreen":1eht0ms6 said:That's me circled. Better view than any camera half way down the pitch. We all agreed it was well over. That's my last post on it, over and out.
Aaron D.":2jnbmskj said:Argyle-sy":2jnbmskj said:To be fair I have only seen the highlights which were shown on Sky's EFL page, and it did look well over from that camera angle, but as others have said camera angles can be deceptive, so I just we will never know unless someone who was directly in line with the incident managed to capture footage of the incident.
You say that, but I sit directly in line with the goal line and the posts exactly for this kind of situation. You have a view where it is very clear if the ball is over the line or not unless a body is in the way. I wasn't there on Saturday but others in line say it was over so for me that's better than any camera footage from an angle. That coupled with the absence of footage from the camera in goal from MM says to me it was a goal alright.
Maybe our luck is beginning to balance itself out...... :scarf: